Transaction Fees vs Monthly Fees: Where the Math Flips
Ecommerce pricing pages show two kinds of cost. A monthly fee stays the same whether you sell or not. A transaction fee looks small on one order and grows with every sale. This guide adds the two together for five tools at three sales levels, using each one’s own pricing page.
Prices are USD, checked in October and November, and card rates are for US online payments. Every example assumes $50 orders paid with a standard domestic card. The sales levels are examples, not benchmarks. The order is alphabetical. It is not a ranking.
BigCommerce
Core is $39 a month, or $29 billed yearly. BigCommerce charges $0 of its own on orders through an embedded payment provider, but the provider’s processing rate is a separate cost. Through an open payment provider, BigCommerce adds 2.0% on Core, 1.0% on Growth and 0.6% on Scale.
The plan depends on your sales. Core runs up to $30K of GMV over the trailing twelve months, Growth at $105 a month up to $100K, and Scale at $399 a month up to $33,333 of GMV a month. BigCommerce counts GMV as gross order value minus 10%. Pass a limit on Core or Growth and the plan upgrades automatically.
Lemon Squeezy
Lemon Squeezy has no monthly charge for ecommerce features. It takes 5% + 50¢ per transaction. Its page adds that some payments may be subject to additional fees.
Shopify
Basic is $25 a month, or $19 billed yearly. Through Shopify Payments, Basic lists a US rate of 2.9% + 30¢ for a standard online card and 3.5% + 30¢ for a premium one.
Use a third-party payment provider instead and Shopify adds its own fee on top of what that provider charges: 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow, 0.6% on Advanced and 0.2% on Plus. Shopify Payments is available only in certain countries, so check yours first. If it is not offered where your business is based, this is the fee you pay.
Stripe
Stripe has no monthly fee. It charges 2.9% + 30¢ per successful transaction on domestic cards, plus 0.5% for manually entered cards and 1.5% for international cards. Stripe takes the payment. The store in front of it is a separate decision and may be a separate bill.
WooCommerce
WooCommerce is a free download with no monthly platform fee. WooPayments, its own payment option, has no monthly fee for online payments and charges 2.90% + $0.30 on US cards, plus 1.50% on international ones. Hosting is a separate bill and is not counted below.
Side by side at three sales levels
Each cell is the monthly plan fee plus transaction fees, with plans billed monthly.
| Setup | $1,000 a month (20 orders) | $5,000 a month (100 orders) | $20,000 a month (400 orders) |
|---|---|---|---|
| BigCommerce, with a provider at 2.9% + 30¢ | $74 | $280 | $1,099 |
| Lemon Squeezy | $60 | $300 | $1,200 |
| Shopify Basic, Shopify Payments | $60 | $200 | $725 |
| Shopify Basic, third-party provider at 2.9% + 30¢ | $80 | $300 | $1,125 |
| Stripe | $35 | $175 | $700 |
| WooCommerce with WooPayments, hosting not included | $35 | $175 | $700 |
The BigCommerce and third-party rows assume a provider that happens to charge 2.9% + 30¢. Your provider’s real rate will differ, so swap it in.
The BigCommerce row also changes plan as sales grow. At $1,000 a month, GMV is $10,800 a year, which fits Core at $39. At $5,000 a month, GMV is $54,000 a year, which puts you on Growth at $105. At $20,000 a month, GMV is $216,000 a year, or $18,000 a month, which puts you on Scale at $399.
Where the math flips
On a $50 order, 5% + 50¢ costs $1.25 more than 2.9% + 30¢. A $25 monthly fee equals that gap at 20 orders. That is why Lemon Squeezy and Shopify Basic both come to $60 at $1,000 in sales. Below that point the percentage-only price is cheaper. Above it, the monthly fee pays for itself, and the gap keeps widening: $100 at $5,000 in sales and $475 at $20,000.
A third-party provider moves the point again. On Shopify, Grow costs $40 more a month than Basic and cuts the third-party fee by one percentage point. If you stay with a third-party provider, that upgrade pays for itself at $4,000 a month in sales.
Before you buy
Estimate your monthly orders and your average order value, then run the sum for the sales you expect a year from now, as well as today. Smaller orders change the result, because the fixed part of the fee weighs more on each one. Add the costs that sit outside the table: hosting, the card types your customers use, and any payment provider you plan to keep.
You can compare these five tools in the ecommerce and payments directory.